One of the few things I miss from living in a large city is the ease with which I could buy my craft supplies. If I wanted to find fabric, notions, paper and such, I lived a 5-minute drive from the largest craft and notions stores in the city. Of course driving was so cumbersome that sometimes, instead of venturing further, I would just order online.
Now living in an outpost there are even fewer choices, but incredibly, for all we miss, we have a craft store in town. Never mind that it is a small shop, that also functions as bookshop and book exchange, at least I can buy essentials and it takes a 5-minute walk from home. I still buy a lot online (fabric, for example), but whenever I can I patronize the local shop.
Something else I like about the shop is that they always have handmade things made by local crafters (amazing how many crafters there are in such a small place as PuntaCana).
If you are around here, drop by and shop some (I gotta keep my purveyors of crafty stuff in business), if you are not, then get inspired with these lovely things.